Do you remember the time when your Instagram feed ran out of content?
It was like checking the fridge for extra food, you could look again to see if there was anything new but eventually you’d get bored and go outside. I’m not old enough to have received the paper once a day but damn that must have been nice.
Nowadays everything has a fucking reels feature. No one is going to buy your chocolate while your competitors are selling 100% pure-grade cocaine.
It might sound crazy to some but what if we like… did something about it? What if we put the technology behind reels on a controlled substance list?
I can already hear the echoes about freedom of speech and free markets blah blah but can we not agree that this shit is bad for us?
It is your monkey brain vs teams of the smartest engineers on the planet with near-infinite resources.
Now I get it, I get it. You’re thinking:
Yo jords what in the fuck, this is a slippery slope! Where does one draw the line with government intervention? Soon we’ll have the government telling us what we can and can’t watch.
1984 Orwell Communism Socialist Sweden.
We always get the same argument when something new is presented. Instead of seeing merit in it we instead go straight to screaming about slippery slopes and Scandinavian countries.
So where do I draw the line you ask? Right about here.
If you don’t want nukes you gotta draw the line somewhere my bro.
I believe features we now consider basic are the biggest destroyer of human capital that has ever existed. So much potential wasted, I even see it in myself.
Things like the infinite scroll, autoplay and push notifications deplete our control until there is barely consent remaining. How many times have you caught yourself in a scroll that was seemingly unconscious?
Now let me meet the free market capitalists right where they stand, before I am accused of being Nordic.
The private labour force is worth trillions of dollars. If you actually add up all of the parents looking after their children, all the people caring for sick family members, all those volunteering. This is all labour that is relatively untracked and unpaid, but extremely important for the function of society.
What if we put a median-wage number and attached it to the average time spent scrolling. Is that a cost to a society? If so, then we are reallocating very real opportunity cost and time spent on autopilot to the top 10% that own MAG7 stock.
If we put the US median hourly wage into the total hours spent on Social Media then the cost is $8.5T per year. That’s a lot of fucking cheese.
I am not arguing that all of this time is wasted. I essentially make my living on Social Media and owe much of my success to it, but there must be a portion of this average consumption time that is directly caused by malicious technical features.
I would estimate a good portion of my own time spent on Social Media is on autopilot and is not used for work or entertainment purposes.
The platforms that exist are simply competing for the most efficient way to extract human attention as a commodity. Surely we can’t agree that doing so is in the best interest of society?
The same way that governments have regulated access to drugs and gambling, we must pass legislation against malicious technical features.
There is a seemingly global movement slowly catching up on Social Media. In Australia there are now bans of social media under 16 years old (thank fuck) but this to me is just a slow step forward vs an opponent that is outpacing us.
Sure society wins if the stock markets go up, but did we agree to this social contract of losing several waking hours each day in order for tech stocks to more profitably shove advertisements down our throats?
I’m sorry if I sound like someone screaming ‘won’t somebody think of the children’ but don’t get me wrong in thinking this is just about the children.
I believe we drastically overrate our own genius when it comes to being able to beat technology.
We justify our inaction by saying that it should be up to each individual to decide how they want to participate in this world but that is based on the assumption we are in control.
When campaigns of banning Social Media for kids began in Australia, parents opposing said that the government was overreaching and started screaming about the ol’ slippery dipperly sloperno. They said that parents should have the right to parent their kids, that if you don’t want your kid on Social Media just don’t give them a phone.
But if you send your kid to a school where every other kid has a phone and your socially able gremlin can’t even clap back with a good meme, do you think they’re going to fit in?
The implied fair and just world where everyone can decide for themselves is outdated. Either no kid has social media in a school or it’s a shitshow trying to manage the in-between.
This problem is more pressing now than it has been in the past decade because we might finally reclaim some of our time.
What if AI actually does take a lot of labour off our hands and we are able to spend more time doing the things we love like Sam Altman and Dario keep promising between drinking mathematician tears and telling everybody they’re about to die.
The answer to me is pretty obvious. If people get more time then they’ll just spend more time scrolling.
We all thought that technology winning would look like The Terminator but the simple answer is that it has already defeated us. The manner of victory just seems a lot more mundane than muscly robots and big guns.
The underlying tech on Social Media right now is too good for our brains. It has been specifically created to target our evolved weaknesses.
Have you ever had a laser pointer and watched a cat run around trying to catch it thinking wow you fucking idiot hahaha.
That’s what we are doing with auto-playing reels but we are too Dunning Kruger’d to believe we are the stupid fucking cats.
We want our pseudo-freedom more than we want the actual freedom to do things we want to do.
But I say treat me like a stupid cat (stroke me). Let’s be honest with ourselves and stop pretending. I can’t beat the algorithm.
If we do not regulate the technology that has already defeated us then any new technology that grants us more time will be wasted.
In times gone by idleness was usually granted off the back of slave labour. Those who inherited great wealth or watched the toil of others could do sweet fuck-all because the work was being done by others.
There would be a great irony in AI becoming the new, finally ethical slave labour-force only for us to become slaves of big-tech for no fucking reason.
In The Matrix humans are farmed by robots for the energy they create.
If we replace energy with our attention and robots with the most well-funded companies in the world, then we are not too far off that reality.
The AI-wet-dream that is being sold of having more time to do things can only be real once we address the vampiric force that sucks at our collective attention.
Now, here we have the same dialogue that I had in the beginning with children. You’re an adult, if you don’t like Social Media then just delete it lol wtf is wrong with chu?
I don’t really see why we should be treated differently than children in this conversation. It is socially isolating to be removed from Social Media and in the midst of a loneliness epidemic it is a hard-sell to go out of your way to further isolate yourself.
By not having Instagram I often miss out on things my friends are doing, but it is a compromise I’m willing to make in order to avoid more time spent on autopilot.
If each day I woke up and there was a line of cocaine on my bedside table I’d probably become a cocaine addict. Some days I’d be able to resist and other days I’d be Charlie Sheening my way through lunch.
If there was a big ‘TURN OFF’ button that tells Instagram to fuck off with their reels and asshole infinite scroll then I’d have less to compromise and maybe it would be worth having.
This year the EU Commission (goats) issued formal preliminary findings against both TikTok and Meta. In their findings they specifically mention features that put users on ‘autopilot mode’ need to be made opt-in. This zombified autopilot state is the enemy.
Call me fragile but this sounds great to me. Give me more control over the things in my life that are bad for me. I like my social media like I like my drugs, taken moderately and not scientifically optimised for over-consumption.
I’d rather take many of the things on the controlled substance lists than scroll uninterrupted for multiple hours per day on reels.
I’m tired of arguing for and against social media I just want these features that are fucking horrendous for us to go away. If they can’t be killed, let them be opt-in. Or I don’t know, something?? Anything??
If we truly need to submit to our new tech overlords, then maybe we can have paid features that allow us to turn these malicious features off.
I don’t know a single person who doesn’t feel a deep urge to reduce their screen time. Everybody is fighting the same battle, somehow without help, against the richest and most powerful of enemies, and most are logically losing.
It’s time to send for back-up.








“The platforms that exist are simply competing for the most efficient way to extract human attention as a commodity.”
Great write up!